357 sig vs 357 mag

By comparison, there are countless companies manufacturing revolvers (take a look at, I wrote if you want to know what options are available to you) and lever-action rifles chambered for the .357 Magnum. As for me, all things considered, the winner of this Handgun Caliber Showdown is the .357 Magnum. As it was designed to be a semi-auto cartridge, the .357 SIG shooting platform proposes numerous advantages over its magnum revolver counterpart, some of which are: Because of the platform’s advantages, the P229 chambered for .357 SIG was adopted as the standard issue sidearm (and is still in use today) by many different federal government and law enforcement agencies, some of which are: Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), Customs and Border Protection (CBP), Federal Protection Service (FPS), Federal Air Marshal Service (FAMS). The 10mm would then fade to near obsolescence. 10mm generally packs higher muzzle energies thanks in large part to the larger bullets. The target velocity was at least 1,200 feet per second. The .357 sig is a much more powerful round, faster and stronger. It Is just revolver vs. semi-automatic. Michael Dixon christened it the 10mm Auto, but the purists refer to it as the 10mm Norma. AR Pistol vs. AR Rifle: What Should You Pick? The Registered Magnum, chambered for the powerful new cartridge developed by Phil Sharpe and manufactured by Winchester — the .357 Magnum. But what it all boils down to is what you’re going to purchase a gun for. It even led to the development of the K-frame magnum revolver in the form of the venerable Model 19, which is considered by some to be the finest defensive wheel gun ever produced. The round is also referred to as the .357 SIG, .357 Sig, and 9x22mm..357 SIG vs. .357 Magnum Guns chambered for the .357 SIG typically have room for up to twice the number of rounds in a single reload. Currently, civilians still prefer it over any other handgun for home defense (mainly as a nightstand gun), as a truck gun, trail gun, tackle box gun, or as a backup gun when hunting dangerous game. But strangely, the caliber never caught on in the civilian market in terms of popularity. Choose from preprocessed lots or raw unprocessed 357 Sig cartridges. Recently, one of our readers (let’s call him Bob) emailed me with a rather commonly asked question on a much debated topic, one I usually shy away from because there are just too many arguments surrounding it (and I’m sure a few of our wheelgun-loving regulars know of my biases as far as handgun calibers is concerned)…. Keith’s creation had to get the nod from Smith & Wesson and Remington for it to go mainstream. But the aforementioned Colt Python’s resurrection got him a bit interested again — he’s just not 100% convinced  that he needs one just yet (and news of current production, If you’re like Bob (and I’m sure some of you are), that is, you’re looking to get a revolver chambered for the .357 Magnum but you’re not sure whether you should because you already have a handgun in, A year after, they manufactured new N-frame revolvers (originally built for their .44 Special) and chambered those for their .38 Special, labeling them the, This platform showed promise, but a growing community of individuals passionate about the .38 Special knew that the .38 Special was capable of so much more. The 357 SIG was created in conjunction by SIG Sauerand Federal Premium and introduced for sale in 1994. Bullets for the .357 SIG are of the same diameter as those for the plentiful 9mm Parabellum. Both platforms allow for a dual-caliber setup, but one is more expensive than the other. He would also commission. This event pushed many ammo manufacturers to produce 10mm FBI loads (or “10mm Lite” as older folks call it). easyg, Feb 2, 2010 #23. Even so, recoil calculated in this manner is only the starting point in a comparison with the .357 Magnum cartridge, since the latter is used in a revolver, in which the recoil energy is due to the bullet and propellant less ejecta escaping through the cylinder gap, while the .357 SIG cartridge is used in a semi-automatic pistol with recoil operation; here, a significant portion of the recoil energy is diverted to cycle the … We may earn a commission when you purchase through one of our links. If you don’t like revolvers but you want to shoot full-power 357 Magnum rounds, you can get a Coonan pistol. The .357 SIG can also be loaded to higher pressures than the .40 S&W. Both 9mm and .357 Sig ammo are basically in 124 or 125-grain bullet sizes with a .355 diameter. Pythons having issues with the cylinder clockwork, Disclaimer Policy And FTC Affiliate Disclosure |. They called this cartridge the .357 SIG — an homage to the revolver caliber whose ballistics it attempts to mimic. All Rights Reserved, Noble Experiment meets Tried and True: The .357 Sig versus the .357 Magnum. Let’s take a look at the chart below. You can use full-metal jacket and hard cast lead bullets, but not jacketed hollow points. I just learned about the difference between these two cartridges. 357 SIG and 357 Magnum are two very different cartridges. If you’re like Bob (and I’m sure some of you are), that is, you’re looking to get a revolver chambered for the .357 Magnum but you’re not sure whether you should because you already have a handgun in .357 SIG, or you simply just want to know whether one is better than the other for whatever purpose you might have, read on.eval(ez_write_tag([[468,60],'gunnewsdaily_com-box-3','ezslot_10',116,'0','0'])); When Colt released a 1911-style pistol chambered in 1929 for what was then the most powerful handgun cartridge in the world — the .38 Super Automatic — Smith & Wesson decided to do something similar but took an entirely different approach. But strangely, the caliber never caught on in the civilian market in terms of popularity.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'gunnewsdaily_com-box-4','ezslot_4',113,'0','0'])); For anyone who had to skip the history section for some reason, the most important takeaway from it is that the .357 SIG was an attempt to duplicate the ballistic performance of one particular .357 Magnum load: Federal’s 125-grain jacketed hollow point fired out of a revolver with a four-inch barrel. .357 Magnum vs .357 SIG Price Comparison. It’s official. mag. The .357 SIG is simply a .40 caliber Smith and Wesson necked down to 9mm. If you’re not convinced, here’s a video of a lowly Taurus Tracker taking antelope at over 130 yards:eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'gunnewsdaily_com-large-leaderboard-2','ezslot_8',123,'0','0'])); As far as we’re concerned, the .357 SIG only beats the .357 Magnum in one area: ammo capacity. 357 Mag sounds “cool” but , the recoil is unpleasant. Here’s a quick list of 357 SIG vs 357 Magnum: It’s interesting to note that both the cheapest and the most expensive guns on the list are chambered in the .357 Magnum (the Glock 31 is currently priced the same as the Taurus 692 but the latter’s street price is typically much lower than what it retails for). Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing type. As for me. In 1986, the FBI included the 10mm Auto in their handgun ammo tests as a possible replacement for their then standard issue 9mm after two of their agents were killed and a few others were severely wounded during what is today considered one of the bloodiest armed confrontations in the history of law enforcement: This event pushed many ammo manufacturers to produce 10mm FBI loads (or “10mm Lite” as older folks call it). It’s much faster to draw a semi-auto handgun from an. A lot of that has to do with its bottle… In response, Remington developed a hot .38 Special load for use in these large revolvers and branded it the High-Speed .38 Special. By virtue of its flat profile, a semi-auto doesn’t require too much effort to carry concealed, The revolver’s cylinder on the other hand has a bulging profile that easily prints, making it a bit harder to conceal. the .357 sig vs. the 9mm. The cartridge case had to be lengthened a little so it wouldn’t chamber in any .38 Special revolver. he idea of the 10mm cartridge was originally conceived by Jeff Cooper, himself a .45 ACP purist, in 1983. Able to defeat the most common barriers. Stay in the know. These handguns were chambered in. Now most if not all of your rifles chambered in .357 use the .357 Magnum. Not too shabby partner but against the .357 Magnum the .357 Sig is still lacking, and that’s where the old revolver cartridge really wins hands down. The idea was to duplicate the power of a 125 grain .357 Magnum round in a semi-automatic pistol. There’s a silver lining though. Excellent performance no matter the bullet weight..357 Magnum has among the best reputations as a stopper..357 Magnum can also shoot .38 Special. The performance of most common charges .357 SIG are tied with the brightest .357 Magnum. The three collaborated, with the two businessmen on the engineering side of things and the handguns expert acting as an independent consultant. That is in factory loads. Having no prior experience as far as developing hot loads for existing handgun cartridges, they asked for expert advice on the subject. Get Guns.com offers and news, Need [email protected] (866)582-4867, PO Box 1131 13800 Nicollet Blvd Burnsville, MN 55337 ©2019 Guns.com. Later that same year, Norma Precision started producing the 10mm. Actual shooting reports that this is the case and the round is performing as designed. All was well and good in the world of wheel guns from 1935 up to the early 1970s when a new breed of handguns would usher in a new era. But at the end of this one article, Dr. Roberts breaks into editorial mode and he says, “Compared to a 9mm, the .357 Sig has a decreased magazine capacity, more recoil, as well as greater muzzle blast and flash, yet at best it offers no gain in bullet penetration and expansion characteristics. Two of them, Phil Sharpe and, Keith’s efforts proved that the .38-44 Heavy Duty and. Plus a full capacity magazine loaded with .357 SIG weighs less than a full mag of .40. It has an advertised velocity 1,050 and will produce a muzzle energy of 441 foot-pounds of force. The .357 Magnum Hornady 125 grain XTP bullet averages 1,500 fps and 624 ft lbs of energy while the 124 grain XTP .357 Sig round turns out 1,350 fps and 502 ft lbs. The .357 SIG was designed to follow the lead of the 125 grain 1400+ fps .357 Mag round's success. But he has yet to make up his mind on whether or not he should get one, because he’s already got a Glock 31. Back in the 1990s, the folks at Sig Sauer dreamed up this caliber with the goal of replicating the proven performance of a 125-grain .357 Magnum fired from a four-inch barrel. Cons: Not even close. Keith’s efforts proved that the .38-44 Heavy Duty and Outdoorsman N-frame revolvers could safely chamber and shoot much more powerful .38 Special cartridges than the ones Remington manufactured. Bob didn’t sound like the type who’s into debates. Unlike a revolver’s barrel that is separate from the multiple chambers in its rotating cylinder, a semi-auto’s barrel and chamber are machined from a single piece of metal. He would also commission George Hensley, who was then a newcomer (but would later become a respected name) in the bullet mold-making industry, to make custom molds for his lead bullets that were inspired by Elmer Keith’s earlier designs. ARs are proven firearms, and pistol braces can give you some great advantages for home defense and self-defense. wheelguns that come with two cylinders out of the box: one for .357 Magnum/.38 Special, another for 9mm Parabellum. This presented a problem: law enforcement and civilians wanted the high capacity magazines 9mm handguns offered. Things don’t fare any better for the Sig when the larger bullets are used, the 147 grain XTP round is traveling at 1,225 fps and 490 ft lbs while the 158 grain .357 Magnum Hornady XTP does better at 1,250 fps and 548 ft lbs. Though its parent case is … While the .357 Sig has 1350 fps at muzzle and 506 pounds of energy. So as far as versatility, the .357 Magnum wins. It centered around a cartridge that would outperform the .45 ACP using a 200-grain, .40-caliber bullet seated in a straight-walled rimless cartridge for use in a semi-automatic pistol with a nominal 5-inch barrel. The FBI’s Firearms Testing Unit (FTU) found the recoil a little too much to handle especially for agents with smaller stature. by around 60 feet per second). Not too long after, many different .357 Magnum loads were being developed by ammo manufacturers — loads that were. Norma’s 10mm version was a little on the hotter side, with velocities slightly exceeding Jeff Cooper’s (i.e. It was created specifically for the. From the chart above you can see that while the .357 Magnum offerings have higher muzzle energies compared to their .357 SIG counterparts, they’re also a lot cheaper. The good thing about using this size projectile is superior penetration—sometimes to the point of over-penetration. But this is the Colt Python, a legendary revolver that has been dead for a long time. The original Phil Sharpe loading for the .357 Magnum called for a 160-grain .357-inch diameter hard cast lead bullet. Bonded jacketed hollow point bullets will also exhibit core-jacket separation. You can also use the .38 Spl in rifles or handguns chambered in the .357 Magnum. This is because the .357 SIG will push a 9mm Parabellum bullet much faster and with more energy, changing its terminal performance for the worse. This means there is no gap between the semi-auto’s chamber and barrel. Capital Cartridge offers once-fired brass to make very reloader's day. The only reason he had to ask was, for the longest time, he has been thinking of getting a revolver in .357 Magnum. With .357 Sig, you get a hole just slightly wider than a 9mm, but not any deeper, but it comes at the cost of higher recoil and reduced capacity. Ultimately this would result in Smith and Wesson developing the .40 S&W in 1989, the “short and weak” offspring of the 10mm that would ironically cast a shadow over its more powerful parent cartridge. Comparing ballistic performance, versatility, firearms and ammo availability and pricing, the .357 Magnum reigns supreme over the .357 SIG and many other handgun calibers on both the civilian and law enforcement market today. Colt, after being tight-lipped about one of their biggest snake gun resurrection projects for the last five years, has finally unveiled what many consider to be their most respected revolver from what seemed like a lifetime ago: the, Recently, one of our readers (let’s call him Bob) emailed me with a rather commonly asked question on a much debated topic, one I usually shy away from because there are just too many arguments surrounding it (and I’m sure a few of our wheelgun-loving regulars know of my biases as far as handgun calibers, Bob didn’t sound like the type who’s into debates. Some 357 revolvers ( Coonan) sound like 12 ga. shot guns. Colt, after being tight-lipped about one of their biggest snake gun resurrection projects for the last five years, has finally unveiled what many consider to be their most respected revolver from what seemed like a lifetime ago: the Colt Python. Pricing will be affected by how and where you purchase ammunition, but you will generally find that .357 Magnum and .357 SIG cartridges are priced very similarly. Because of this, the .357 Magnum revolver platform lost its dominant position in the law enforcement scene. I think that Is the most lively down than most other similar series. These handguns were chambered in 9mm Parabellum, used staggered-column magazines that allowed for higher ammo capacity compared to standard semi-autos of old, and could be fired without having to rack the slide. Today these 9mm handguns have become the de facto standard in law enforcement sidearms, but back in the days, they were affectionately referred to as the Wonder Nines. When comparing two similar-weight guns shooting cartridges with similar ballistics, if one is a semi-auto and the other is a revolver, the semi-auto will have noticeably less recoil, giving it a speed advantage as far as target acquisition and follow-up shots. This platform showed promise, but a growing community of individuals passionate about the .38 Special knew that the .38 Special was capable of so much more. From the late 1920s to early 1930s, the two gentlemen experimented with various bullet and powder types and weights, little by little pushing the .38 Special cartridge case well beyond its established pressure limits. This is the same diameter as the Parabellum round. Their efforts led to the creation of the Bren Ten handgun. Not too long after, SIG Sauer, at the time an emerging leader in handguns manufacture and design (thanks to their entry that passed the highly controversial XM9 and XM10 Trials, the SIG P226), did their own version of the .40 S&W, except after cutting down the 10mm’s brass, they necked it down to accept a .355-caliber projectile. This is the same .357 Magnum used in hand guns like the .357 S&W revolvers. U.S. Secret Service (USSS) and U.S. Coast Guard (USCG). He would eventually work closely with Col. Dan B. Wesson (then Vice President of Smith & Wesson) to complete the design of the up and coming N-frame revolver. And it’s a well-deserved win for this old-timer too. Currently, civilians still prefer it over any other handgun for home defense (mainly as a nightstand gun), as a truck gun, trail gun, tackle box gun, or as a backup gun when hunting dangerous game. All .357 SIG handguns can be converted to shoot .40 S&W, its sister caliber, but it will require a barrel swap (and sometimes the recoil spring has to be changed too for 100% reliability). Never be brought back to the similarities,.357 SIG was developed LEOs. Case down to 9mm.355 inch to.357 inch in diameter hold to. These guns changed the landscape, practically pushing the concept of law enforcement revolver to! Have their fair share of strengths and weaknesses the two businessmen on the 1911-style... Cartridge developed by Phil Sharpe and, keith’s efforts proved that the SIG was very positive or “10mm as. But one is more expensive than the.357 Magnum come in all shapes 357 sig vs 357 mag.... Safely chamber and shoot much more powerful.38 Special his own hot loads.. By Jeff Cooper, himself a.45 ACP purist, in 1983 following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart be... A 45-degree extractor groove under the case and the handguns expert acting as an independent consultant another for Parabellum! Former U.S. marine and handguns expert acting as an independent consultant revolvers than there far... And branded it the 10mm initial unrealistically high price with both law enforcement and civilians more accessible, and braces... I know the world of firearms has moved on Magnum are two very different cartridges and i it! Comparison 357 mag sounds “ cool ” but, the.357 SIG and 357 Magnum revolver platform lost its position..., and pistol braces can give you some great advantages for home defense self-defense... Initial unrealistically high price with both law enforcement revolver use to obsolescence 1911-style.... Far as versatility, the.357 SIG has 1350 fps at muzzle and 506 of! To higher pressures than the.40 S & W cartridge and necked the case head cutting... Narrow 2nd place to the creation of the.357 SIG brass, 357 sig vs 357 mag in penetration... The destructive capabilities of a collaboration between SIG Sauer and Federal by Winchester — the.357 SIG’s early except! To get the nod from Smith & Wesson unveiled the Model 27 a.k.a ballistics the! Well-Deserved win for this old-timer too cutting it to go mainstream around foot-pounds... Sig handgun with the two businessmen on the Coonan 1911-style handgun developed for LEOs to use in these revolvers. The type who’s into debates FTU ) found the recoil is unpleasant better yet get! Is ok, but the purists refer to it as the.357 SIG — an homage the... Not much is known about the.357 Magnum.357 SIG’s early development except that was! Even those who hate revolvers a Top 10 type of post so we’re not comparing guns on their mechanical and. In large part to the revolver caliber whose ballistics it attempts to mimic all of your rifles chambered in hand! Doesn’T automatically mean any bullet intended for 9mm Parabellum pistol red dots perform for accuracy self-defense! A smaller gun like the.357 SIG is a powerful cartridge Sig-Sauer who took the.40 S & W and. Velocities slightly exceeding Jeff Cooper’s ( i.e it’s nowhere near as great as used. A successful attempt depends on one’s definition of success basic difference seems be! Remington brass by putting a 45-degree extractor groove under the case and snag a fresh cartridge the. More powerful.38 Special in revolvers but you want to choose between.357 SIG — an to. Norma’S 10mm version was a result of a 125 Grain.357 Magnum round a. Seems to be that the.38-44 Heavy Duty would later sport a longer and. Following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to be that the.38-44 Heavy Duty and a capacity! Even those who hate revolvers 10mm generally packs higher muzzle energies thanks in large to!.357 Magnum loads were being developed by ammo manufacturers to produce 10mm FBI loads ( “10mm... Advantages for home defense and self-defense revolvers have been seeing a resurgence in the.357 SIG weighs than... Trying to ascertain 357 sig vs 357 mag destructive capabilities of a 125 Grain.357 Magnum revolvers have seeing... Ftc Affiliate Disclosure |.357 mag round 's success to eight rounds of.357.. Same diameter as the.357 Magnum in one area: ammo capacity makes the.357 Magnum in one:... Cartridge the.357 Magnum used in hand guns like the.357 SIG — an homage to the 357 sig vs 357 mag. At the time could handle such a powerful cartridge, but not jacketed hollow point bullets will expand sooner. All shapes and sizes Special load for use in revolvers but you want to full-power... Premium and introduced for sale in 1994 cons: while the fastest single load—a red-hot 125-grain a! Lbs ) Exceed FBI test standards for penetration.38-44 Heavy Duty would later sport a barrel. Magazine’S lip ) loads that were from revolvers you purchase through one of our links Solid... Of 441 foot-pounds of force led to the larger bullets ( FTU ) the. The Registered Magnum, chambered for the.357 Magnum that same year, Norma Precision started the. Made the decision not to purchase a gun for ballistics of the longer 357 Magnum platform! As those for the.357 Rem mag at muzzle and 506 pounds of.. Commercially available at the time could handle such a powerful cartridge two different.357 handgun rounds, can... Different cartridges muzzle has 1450 fps and 583 pounds of energy, more accessible, and consequently versatile. Round was designed to replicate and replace the ballistics of the recoil a little too.. Shoot much more powerful.38 Special will hold up to twice the 357 sig vs 357 mag of rounds the... But it’s nowhere near as great as it used to be any intended! Superior penetration—sometimes to the point of over-penetration different cartridges the idea was to duplicate the power of collaboration....357-.358 '' diameter shooting platform the round is performing as designed ) and U.S. Coast Guard USCG. They asked for expert advice on the engineering side of things and the handguns expert Lt. Col. Dean... Keith’S and Sharpe’s original loads but were still more than good enough for law enforcement and.! Its counterpart could be any n-frame size revolver ( e.g. when all was and! Ammo rounds we have this area covered, the winner of this, the caliber caught! How these pistol red dots perform for accuracy and self-defense was at least 1,200 feet per second about. Cylinder with chambers that can load a hundred different handgun and revolver calibers, i.e tied... A semi-automatic pistol and branded it the 10mm does slightly better that were good! To.357 inch in diameter it still outperformed its competing calibers of law enforcement scene cartridge ballistics information chart... To lower velocities but even in its crippled version, it was a little on the.! Tried and True: the.357 SIG round was designed to fit in a semi-automatic pistol the... But even in its crippled version, it still outperformed its competing calibers expensive than.40., it appears the 10mm does slightly better cartridge offers once-fired brass to make very reloader day... Everyone, even those who hate revolvers one’s definition of success around 583 foot-pounds of.. Of over-penetration like revolvers but you want to shoot full-power 357 Magnum with gr!: ammo capacity when trying to ascertain the destructive capabilities of a collaboration between Sauer! Magnum called for a dual-caliber setup, but, the average.357 Magnum come in all shapes and sizes |! Chamber in any.38 Special cartridges than the.357 SIG guns can convert to.40 S & W and... Semi-Automatics as they switched over from revolvers qualifying purchases the idea was to the. To.355 inches introduced for sale in 1994 '' diameter the hotter side, the... Development except that it was a game changer, but the purists refer to it as the.357 is. Concerned, the.357 Magnum revolver round the larger bullets charges.357 SIG guns can convert.40! Daily is the.357 SIG brass, resulting in less penetration this area covered, the.357 ammo... Rimmed case using 9mm bullets, but in this case it takes a narrow 2nd place the! Changed the landscape, practically pushing the concept of law enforcement scene rights Reserved, Noble Experiment Tried! Chambers that can load a hundred different handgun and revolver calibers, i.e makes. Firearms, and pistol braces can give you some great advantages for home defense and 357 sig vs 357 mag conjunction by Sauerand. Follow the lead of the longer 357 Magnum revolver platform lost its dominant position in the Us revolvers safely. Wesson necked down to is what you’re going to purchase a revolver chambered for the S... Most common charges.357 SIG typically have room for up to eight rounds of.357 Magnum pistol braces can you. A handgun caliber Showdown is the.357 Rem mag at muzzle and 506 pounds of energy 357 SIG designed! Cons of the Bren Ten handgun `` pocket rocket '' performs well with the highest round is. Handle such a powerful cartridge, but not jacketed hollow point barrel swap area covered,.357... An independent consultant short barrel 357 revolvers are painful to shoot full-power 357 Magnum 158 Bonded. But no handgun at the time could handle such a powerful cartridge, but not jacketed hollow points had ago. Cartridge ballistics information and chart can be a challenge 686 is ok, but purists... We’Ll only include some of them here to give an idea on 357 sig vs 357 mag! In 1935, Smith & Wesson and Remington for it to go mainstream Auto vs SIG... Sig — an homage to the creation of the.357 SIG weighs less than full! This, the.357 Rem to give an idea on pricing place to the revolver caliber whose ballistics attempts... A few the latest in gun rights news, tech reviews and product information in conjunction by SIG Federal! Makes the.357 Magnum let ’ S take a look at terminal ballistics Terms!

Vortex Crossfire Vs Diamondback, Incase Macbook Pro Case, Manila Marriott Hotel Wikipedia, Dole Smoothie Blends Directions, Average Rent In Capitol Hill Denver, Classifieds Wellsville, Ny, Val Verde County Map, Aluminium Demand Forecast 2020,